In this case, Stuart A. Carpey represented an individual who was forced off of a roof  at his home by Philadelphia police officers and when he landed on the ground he broke his heel bone and required surgery to repair it. Mr Carpey was able to prove that the entry into Robinson's home was unlawful. The police essentially forced Robinson onto the roof, and then he fell off the roof when one of the officers was trying to grab him.  No arrest was made by the police. Although the facts were vehemently disputed by the City of Philadelphia, the City settled before trial for $175,000.

This appellate case handled by Stuart A. Carpey changed the law in Pennsylvania to improve the rights of  Pennsylvania car accident victims. The case stands for the proposition that in specific situations car accident victims can "stack" their medical coverage in order to get their medical bills paid.